Dialogic Leadership in Schools
In schools, we talk constantly. We meet, consult, discuss, debate, and present. And yet, I often sense a silent frustration: despite all this talk, our collective thinking doesn’t always deepen, nor does direction setting always lead to clarity.
Not too long ago, I sat in a staff meeting that looked, on the surface, like a model of collaboration. The agenda was clear. Voices were invited and people spoke thoughtfully and respectfully. When the meeting ended, there was a sense of relief. We had “covered” the issues. But reflecting, in the days that followed, nothing really shifted. The same disconnects about assessment and reporting resurfaced in hallways and the staff room. Uncertainty lingered. So looking back at that meeting, I’m coming to believe that what we had shared was airtime, not understanding for forward motion.
That experience and others like it have stayed with me because it revealed something subtle but important: conversation alone does not produce clarity. I’ve recently learned about “dialogic leadership” as a way of understanding leadership itself as relational, conversational work.
From Talk to Dialogue
One of the most common leadership missteps I’ve made is assuming that conversation automatically leads to understanding. Early in my career, I believed that if I just created space for people to speak, clarity would naturally follow. Over time, I’ve learned that this isn’t always true. Nor is it as simple as making time and space.
William Isaacs (1999) draws an important distinction between discussion (which often prioritizes advocating positions and moving toward conclusions) and dialogue, which is concerned with thinking together. I see this difference play out regularly in schools. In discussions, we often come prepared with solutions. In dialogue, we come prepared with questions.
In practice, dialogic leadership has meant slowing down meetings and conversations. It looks like pausing an agenda item to ask, “What assumptions are we making here?” or “What might we be missing?” It looks like resisting the urge to summarize too quickly, even when time is tight and we sense the meeting is at risk of tedium. I’ve found that schools are full of discussion. Dialogue, however, takes deliberate effort.
Leadership as Meaning-Making
I’ve noticed that when I rush conversations toward decisions, I often get compliance without commitment. People nod and the work technically moves forward but folks don’t feel a shared clarity. David Bohm’s (2004) work helped me understand why. He suggests that meaning does not reside inside individuals, waiting to be extracted, but emerges between people through sustained, attentive conversation.
In schools, this kind of meaning-making often happens in unexpected moments. Consider a school-based team that lingers after a morning meeting to keep talking, a teacher who re-frames a point of perspective and shifts the group’s thinking, or a student voice that unsettles our assumptions. Dialogic leadership asks me to notice and protect these moments rather than rushing past them.
This requires a shift in our own leadership stance: from certainty to curiosity, from control to convening, and from answers to inquiry. I’m not looking to make leadership easier. Instead, I’m seeking to make my conversations more fulfilling and any decisions more grounded.
Dialogue as a Moral Act
Some of the most important lessons I’ve learned about dialogue came from moments when voices were technically invited but not truly heard. Paulo Freire (1970) reminds us that authentic dialogue is inseparable from questions of power, voice, and dignity. I’ve seen how easily well intentioned consultation can still privilege the most confident or comfortable voices in the room.
In schools, dialogic leadership has meant being more intentional. It looks like interrupting patterns where the same few people always speak first. It looks like creating space for written reflection before discussion so quieter voices can enter the creative space. It looks like treating student and family experiences as strong sources of knowledge, rather than novel anecdotes to be acknowledged and set aside.
Handled this way, relational dialogue becomes an ethical commitment.
Presence, Relationship, and Encounter
There are moments in leadership when technique falls away and only presence remains. Martin Buber’s philosophy helped me name these moments. In I and Thou, Buber (1970) distinguishes between transactional relationships and genuine encounters, where people meet one another with openness rather than role or status.
In schools, I see this most when a difficult conversation doesn’t resolve neatly but still strengthens trust. It shows up when I say, “I don’t have this figured out yet,” and mean it. Dialogic leadership, for me, means learning to stay present with discomfort and especially present when conversations surface fear, frustration, or fatigue.
Don’t expect these moments to be efficient. But I believe they are often the ones people remember, because they signal that my leadership is happening with them, not to them.
Dialogue in Educational Practice
Much of what I now think of as dialogic leadership already exists in strong educational practices. Halbert and Kaser’s (2022) emphasis on listening deeply before acting mirrors what I’ve seen in effective school teams. When leaders begin with curiosity, staff are more willing to stay engaged through uncertainty.
In day-to-day school life, dialogic leadership looks practical rather than philosophical. It looks like designing staff meetings around fewer questions and more thinking time. It looks like asking learning teams to share what they are noticing before what they are proposing. It looks like returning to a conversation weeks later and naming how collective thinking has shifted.
Over time, I’ve learned that the difference lies less in the structures we use and more in the quality of attention we bring to them.
A Reflective Question
Dialogic leadership does not promise agreement. It offers something more demanding: the possibility of shared understanding in the midst of difference or uncertainty.
Rather than asking whether everyone agrees, dialogic leadership invites school leaders to first ask: “Are our conversations helping us think more deeply together and generate new understandings?“
It’s tempting to jump to the end, but in times of uncertainty, the quality of our conversations may be the clearest indicator of the kind of leadership we are practicing.
References
Bohm, D. (2004). On dialogue (2nd ed.). Routledge
Buber, M. (1970). I and thou (W. Kaufmann, Trans.). Scribner’s Sons.
Freire, P. (2000). Pedagogy of the oppressed (M. B. Ramos, Trans.; 30th anniversary ed.). Bloomsbury Academic.
Halbert, J., & Kaser, L. (2022). Leading through spirals of inquiry: For equity and quality. Portage & Main Press.
Isaacs, W. (1999). Dialogue and the art of thinking together. Currency.